Previous Up Next

US weapons on June 23, 2004

Taiwan urged to buy US weapons

ARMS BUDGET: According to the delegation visiting Washington, US officials said that if Taiwan does not treat its national defense seriously, then the US won't either
By Charles Snyder and Debby Wu
STAFF REPORTERS IN WASHINGTON AND TAIPEI
 

US Deputy Secretary of Defense Paul Wolfowitz has expressed serious concern about Taiwan's ability to protect itself against possible attacks by China, and urged Taiwan to strengthen its defenses with the proposed arms purchase, according to a Taiwanese legislator visiting Washington.

According to Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) Legislator Lee Wen-chung, Wolfowitz said that if Taiwan does not treat its national defense seriously, then the Americans won't either.

Wolfowitz said that if Taiwan did not take action as soon as possible to strengthen its defenses, China would be encouraged to invest more on military equipment, Lee told the Taipei Times after he and a multi-party legislative delegation headed by Legislative Speaker Wang Jin-pyng spent a day in Washington discussing Taiwan's arms procurement budget with top defense and State Department officials.

The 15-member delegation was briefed by 25 US military and civilian officials during a breakfast meeting on the first day of a three-day visit on Monday morning, and then went off to separate meetings at the Pentagon and the State Department.

Although Wang is from the pan-blue camp, he still showed support for the purchase.

"The balance of military power on the two sides [of the Taiwan Strait] is necessary to the area's peace, stability and prosperity," Wang said.

The delegation was to attend a congressional meeting yesterday to discuss the prospects for a measure before the US Congress to enhance military relations between the US and Taiwan through greater joint activities and mutual visits by top officials who are currently barred from such visits by long-term US policy.

That measure, proposed by Senator Sam Brownback, is expected to come up for a vote this week. The House recently approved a parallel bill.

On Monday, American officials were "vague" about the US' commitment to help Taiwan fend off an attack from China, Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) Legislator Sun Kuo-hua  told the Taipei Times.

After the US officials insisted that it would be in Taiwan's best interests to buy the weapons stipulated in the special budget package -- diesel submarines, P-3C anti-submarine aircraft and Patriot anti-missile systems -- the legislators received somewhat unsatisfactory answers to their questions, Sun said.

When asked if the US would come to Taiwan's defense against China if it were to buy all the weapons, the US side was "vague," Sun said, "because they couldn't say they wouldn't come to our defense, because if they said that, Beijing would say, `Okay, let's attack.'"

"I think the United States is keeping that deliberately vague," he said.

Washington has long been pressuring Taiwan to buy the robust weapons package US President George W. Bush promised in April 2001.

Meanwhile, Pentagon officials were still unable to provide details on the design and cost of the eight diesel submarines included in the package, Sun said.

"We didn't even see a configuration for the submarines ... there's a lot of uncertainties in the cost estimates," he said. "The United States Navy doesn't know."

Sun indicated that Washington was still looking toward various European countries to provide the designs.

But the US officials "gave no indication where the subs will come from" and could not provide a price estimate, Sun said.

"They could only give a rough estimate. We want them to be more accurate," he said.

"How can we approve the cost in the budget if we don't know?" he said.

US shipbuilding companies, "cannot build diesel submarines," because they have not manufactured any for more than 40 years, Sun said.

 

 

 

 

Arms aid is a fit tribute to Reagan

By Paul Lin
 

The Pentagon's Annual Report on the Military Power of the People's Republic of China which was recently presented to Congress, noted that the possibility has been raised in some quarters that as a counter-threat against Chinese aggression, Taiwan could consider targeting densely populated cities or high-value infrastructure projects such as the Three Gorges Dam. Beijing responded violently to the suggestion, and according to a source close to the People's Liberation Army (PLA), quoted by the Straits Times of Singapore, the PLA countered that it not only had more than adequate resources to protect the Three Gorges Dam, but also that it had the capacity to target major dams in the US.

This shows the same attitude as Deputy Chief of the General Staff Xiong Guangkai's  statement in 1995, in which he threatened to launch nuclear missiles at Los Angeles if the US came to the defense of Taiwan. The Global Times, a newspaper under the umbrella of the People's Daily, has also quoted military sources as saying that if Taiwan launched a bombing raid against the Three Gorges Dam, the PLA would respond with sufficient force to "annihilate" Taiwan.

Even before this, a so-called military scholar, Xin Qi , had spoken of "wiping out" Taiwan in a statement made in April 2000, a clear indication that China's vicious ambition to obliterate Taiwan predates and is not related to the suggestion of targeting the Three Gorges Dam.

The reason the Chinese leadership dares make continual military threats is that Taiwan is seen as unable to strike back. For this reason, they are willing to boast that they will pay any price in human lives or economic loss to achieve their goal of unification.

If Taiwan had medium-range missiles that could threaten the Zhongnanhai compound in Beijing or Yuquanshan, the headquarters of the Central Military Commission, threatening the lives of the warmongers without endangering innocent civilians, then they would not be so bold as to make their crazy threats.

The Chinese leadership is afraid of the US because it has missiles that have pinpoint accuracy and are able to penetrate underground bunkers. The Gulf War and the accidental 1999 bombing of the Chinese embassy in Belgrade have taught former president Jiang Zemin to fear American might. The Chinese leaders dare not act directly against Taiwan but instead try to disrupt Taiwan-US relations.

China has also supplied weapons to Pakistan, including nuclear weapon technology, as a means of hemming in India, a country rather similar to China in some ways and a competitor in terms of economic and population growth. China even went to war with India in the early 1960s.

In January 2002, India successfully tested the Agni Ⅱ medium-range ballistic missile. It has a range of 2,500km, which could hit targets anywhere in Pakistan and in large areas of China. India is currently developing the Agni Ⅲ long-range ballistic missile, which would be able to target the densely populated cities of eastern and northeastern China. In January 2001, Vasudev Aatre, the scientific advisor to India's defense minister, pointed out that the new missile would be tested later that year. It was no secret that this missile was being developed as a deterrent to China.

The chairman of the Central Military Commission, Jiang Zemin , met with George Fernandes, India's Minister of Defense, who had been accused by the Chinese of being a "China baiter." Jiang said that China and India were two of the world's largest developing economies and were also neighbors, adding that China was willing to live in harmony with India on the basis of the Five Principles of Peaceful Coexistence with both countries respecting and trusting each other. This is simply an example of the despicable behavior of a hooligan nation, which bullies the weak and fears the strong.

Taiwan's nuclear development program was stopped by the US. Now that China's military capability is surging ahead, it is the responsibility of the US to protect Taiwan, not only through the sale of weapons, but also through support in such research and development. If Taiwan had missiles that could hit locations where China's leaders live, then the potential for conflict in the Taiwan Strait would be greatly reduced, and the chance of the US becoming embroiled in such a conflict would also be reduced.

Once Taiwan has acquired these missiles, it could make a statement rejecting their preemptive use, but retaining the right to use them in retaliation. This was the attitude China adopted when it began its nuclear program, After World War II, the military blocs of the East and West avoided nuclear devastation by creating a "balance of terror." In 1962, then president John Kennedy successfully resisted the threat of Soviet missile deployment in Cuba. The current cross-strait crisis also needs such mighty means and US boldness to achieve a resolution. Such a move would be the greatest possible memorial to all the late president Ronald Reagan sought to achieve.

Paul Lin is a political commentator based in New York.

 

Gods Among Us
Worshippers from the Chuyuan Temple dressed as gods participate in a religious procession to mark the Dragon Boat Festival yesterday. The temple, located in the Choumei borough of Taipei's Peitou district, is the only one in Taiwan dedicated to the worship of Chu Yuan, an ancient poet and courtier who is memorized by the annual festival.


Previous Up Next