|
Agriculture deserves more support
By Lei Li-fen 雷立芬
Saturday, Jul 24, 2010, Page 8
Last weekend, I visited some friends in Yunlin. Leaving
Taipei, the scenery along the highway gradually changed from densely populated
residential areas to large paddy fields that had just been harvested. Any
traveler would be happy to see rolling fields of green as they pass by, but the
owners of this land want these fields to be turned into land for construction
because they see it as a way to get the cash rolling in. From this perspective,
it is difficult to understand why farmers in Dapu Borough (大埔), Miaoli County,
have recently protested the expropriation of their land.
Nobody would believe that Taiwan could face a food shortage, especially when
they see all the different varieties of foods available.
As wheat, corn and bean production decreases around the world, so long as
farmers are willing to plant rice, we can be sure that we will at least have
rice to fill our stomachs, even if we can’t buy food at high prices on
international markets.
However, all hardworking farmers are not necessarily altruists who want to
provide food for everyone. Many of them perhaps have no other choice but to make
a living through agriculture. Therefore, when discussing whether we should
protect agriculture, keep farmland, or give extra assistance to farmers, we
would perhaps be able to arrive at a more objective view if we put ourselves in
the shoes of other people.
Farmland expropriation in Dapu does not revolve around a single issue. It also
involves the way in which the government overlooked public opinion when the
Economic Cooperation Framework Agreement (ECFA) was signed, as well as the
dissatisfaction that was caused when the Rural Revitalization Act (農村再生條例) was
passed.
I am sure most people would be quite happy if they could sell off a piece of
farmland for a price several times higher than the going market rate.
However, land expropriation involves the government forcing land owners to sell
their land at a rate decided by the government.
Those unwilling to have their land expropriated worry about disrespecting their
ancestors, and they also worry about whether the compensation offered by the
government will be adequate to support their families.
The ECFA early harvest list added 18 agricultural products that will receive
tariff-free treatment when exported to China.
However, will the farmers who produce other agricultural products benefit from
this? Will the NT$150 billion (US$4.7 billion) compensation that was part of the
Rural Revitalization Act really reach rural districts and farmers?
If the government’s planned policies do not offer reasonable compensation to
those affected and are not implemented smoothly, even more protests could
follow. The government’s claim that they followed “standard procedure, and so
had no softer approach” in the expropriation of farmland shows a lack of empathy
toward farmers.
The government did nothing to help the situation and only served to further
infuriate the farmers.
I have a friend who wants to find about 200 hectares of farmland to plant
lychees for export. At a time when most people do not hold high hopes for
agriculture, this should be encouraged by the government. However, my friend has
had to work alone and without government help trying to find people to assist
him in purchasing and renting land.
The government cannot wait to tear up rice fields about to be harvested, showing
complete disregard for agriculture. In the case of my friend, the disregard is
due to the fact that lychees make a far smaller contribution to the economy than
wafer foundries and panel production.
A few friends in Yunlin form a complete supply chain for the sale of animal
feed, breeding, slaughtering and processing. They often make more than NT$100
million in annual income, which shows that agriculture is not necessarily as bad
as people believe it to be. In addition, they also enjoy the sort of freedom
that can only be enjoyed by living in rural districts.
A diverse society should protect the rights of people to work in all types of
industries and respect different lifestyles.
Without farmland there can be no agriculture, without agriculture there will be
no farmers and without farmers, we would have no rural districts.
The government should take the agriculture issues that lie behind the farmland
expropriation seriously.
Lei Li-fen is a professor in the Department of Agricultural
Economics at National Taiwan University.
|
