|
Beaten protester to get compensation
PRECEDENT-SETTING CASE: Video footage showed Ted Chiang was looking away from
the police line before he was dragged underneath riot shields and beaten with a
club
By Vincent Y. Chao
Staff Reporter
Friday, Sep 17, 2010, Page 1
“I had a serious concussion ... it felt like I was on a
rollercoaster ride.”－Ted Chiang, alleged victim of police brutality
Ted Chiang, a research student at National
Taiwan University, stems blood flowing from a head wound while receiving
treatment after allegedly being struck on the head by riot police in November
2008. This photo was used as court evidence in January last year.
PHOTO: YANG KUO-WEN, TAIPEI TIMES
The Taipei High Administrative Court has ruled that a protester who was dragged
and beaten by unidentified police officers during demonstrations against Chinese
envoy Chen Yunlin (陳雲林) in Taipei in 2008 was eligible to receive national
compensation after video evidence revealed that he was unarmed and was facing
away from police.
In the first compensation decision over the police response to the protests in
November 2008, the court said on Wednesday that the Taipei City Government would
have to pay Ted Chiang (江一德), a graduate student at National Taiwan University
at the time, NT$300,000 in damages and NT$1,680 in medical costs.
The identity of the officers involved in the act was not revealed in the ruling
and the officers have yet to be disciplined amid claims of a cover-up after the
incident.
In its verdict on the precedent-setting case, the court said police officers
failed to intervene after the clubbing, even as Chiang lay on the ground
bleeding. The ruling added that the Taipei City Government failed to account for
public safety and that there was a lack of police discipline.
Chiang told the Taipei Times yesterday he was satisfied with
the ruling, adding that “it was never about the money — it was about principle
and concern over the conduct of police.”
Chiang, who now works as a marketing manager, said he joined the demonstration
after seeing footage on TV of police confiscating the national flag as part of
the crackdown on the protests.
Soon after the attack, Chiang filed a lawsuit against the commanding officer at
the scene. After he lost the lawsuit, he applied for national compensation from
the Taipei City Government.
While Taipei Mayor Hau Lung-bin (郝龍斌) yesterday said the city government would
not appeal, opposition lawmakers said they hoped the case would reinvigorate
other cases of alleged police brutality currently in court.
“In the past, the court always sided against the public on these issues,”
Democratic Progressive Party Legislator Wong Chin-chu (翁金珠) said. “This time,
however, the judge stood up for the public interest and protected our
constitutionally protected freedom of expression.”
Chiang’s lawyer, Wong Kuo-yan (翁國彥), said he respected the Taipei City
Government’s decision not to appeal, but said city authorities would have to
“determine clearly which [police officers] were involved in the incident.”
The scuffle took place late on the night of Nov. 6, 2008, after about 2,000
students and activists surrounded and blockaded the Grand Formosa Regent hotel,
where Chen was attending a dinner hosted by then-Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT)
chairman Wu Poh-hsiung (吳伯雄).
Hundreds of police in full riot gear later descended on the protesters and
escorted the Chinese envoy out of the hotel at about 2am, resulting in clashes
with the mostly unarmed crowd. The rally was dispersed shortly thereafter, but
not before allegations of police brutality surfaced.
“We were shocked at what took place that night,” Chiang said.
Video footage showed that along with several other white-shirted protesters,
Chiang was looking away from the police line before he was dragged underneath
riot shields and beaten with a club.
“Just as I was getting up again, a blow smashed into the back of my head. My
whole body went limp and it felt like I was getting shocked by a taser,” he
said.
“I had a serious concussion and for a month every time I closed my eyes, it felt
like I was on a rollercoaster ride — everything would spin round and round,” he
said, adding that his wound required seven stitches.
The cases of police brutality that surfaced following the sporadic protests held
throughout that week prompted 25 civic groups and 218 academics to file a
petition with the Control Yuan calling for an investigation into the entire
National Police Agency-led crackdown.
Hundreds of university students also took part in sit-ins in front of the
Executive Yuan and at Liberty Square days later in protest over the police’s
actions.
According to the agency, 27 officers of the about 3,000 deployed were injured
during the week of protests.
The government maintains that police action taken during “Operation Concord,” as
the crackdown was known, was justified.
Taipei City Police Department Spokesman Chou Shou-sung (周壽松) declined to say
whether the force would take action against the officers who injured Chiang.
|
