|
Control Yuan report
to remain secret
MISREPRESENTATION: The Control Yuan probe is
said to have revealed misconduct by Vanessa Shih, though the Ministry of Foreign
Affairs said she had done a good job
By Stacy Hsu / Staff writer
The Control Yuan is said to have secretly concluded an investigation into an
alleged incident involving Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs Vanessa Shih (史亞平)
during her tenure as representative to Singapore, in a report that allegedly
concludes the representative office in Singapore was responsible for “a major
violation of law and dereliction of duty.”
The Chinese-language China Times reported yesterday that the Control Yuan-led
investigation launched following Shih’s recall as representative to Singapore —
a move widely believed to be the result of souring bilateral relations —
concluded on June 20 that “a significant violation of law and serious
dereliction of duty had been committed by the representative office.”
However, as a result of the -“delicate nature of Taiwan-Singapore relations” and
concern that the report could damage the national interest, the Presidential
Office and the Ministry of Foreign Affairs allegedly convinced the Control Yuan
to conclude the probe in secret, the report said.
Those involved have been neither impeached nor disciplined, the report said.
The Singaporean government reportedly voiced dissatisfaction with Shih’s
behavior after the former representative allegedly displayed the Republic of
China (ROC) flag and sang the national anthem without official consent during
the city-state’s national day last year.
A purported meeting between Shih and Chen Show Mao (陳碩茂), a member of
Singapore’s opposition Workers’ Party, was also said to have infuriated former
Singaporean prime minister Lee Kuan Yew (李光耀).
In November last year, the representative office was not invited to a centennial
commemoration of the Hsinhai Revolution, which was jointly organized by Taiwan’s
National Sun Yet-sen Memorial Hall and its counterpart in Singapore.
The event not only galvanized public concern over the state of diplomatic ties
between Taiwan and Singapore, but also prompted Control Yuan member Chou Yang-shan
(周陽山), who was invited to the memorial, to initiate the probe into exchanges
between the two countries.
According to sources familiar with the matter, the “series dereliction of duty”
referred to in the report was Shih’s “inappropriate conduct” in her exchanges
with Singaporean government officials that were said to have had a negative
impact on the bilateral relations.
The “major violation of law” referred to the refusal by former representative
office division chief Chang Shih-jui (張詩瑞) to answer questions when called to a
meeting with Control Yuan members dealing with the case, the source said, an act
that constituted a violation of the Control Act (監察法).
Sources said that given the major changes in Taiwan-Singapore relations,
bilateral ties could be damaged “irreparably” if key parts of the report were
made public.
Confirming receipt of the report late last month, Minister of Foreign Affairs
Timothy Yang (楊進添) said the ministry would review the content and take action on
the proposals made by Control Yuan members where necessary, and would seek to
clarify any misunderstandings with the agency before a specified deadline.
The ministry believes Shih performed well during her term as representative to
Singapore and did not commit any breach of duty, Yang said.
Quoting a ministry official, the Chinese-language United Evening News wrote
yesterday that the Control Yuan report did not accuse Shih of committing major
breaches of duty, but rather instructed her to “engage in introspection and
actively deal with the matter.”
On the controversy over the commemoration event, the official said that Shih was
absent because of a request from the embassy of the People’s Republic of China,
which did not participate in the organization of the event, to send delegates.
Although the Singapore officials declined the request, saying the activity was
purely academic in nature, Shih was still asked not to attend the memorial to
avoid any complications, the official said.
In a press conference held to explain the situation, Shih, who was appointed to
her position at the ministry on July 6, said she took the report very seriously
and that it was for the members of the Control Yuan to determine whether she had
committed any misconduct while in Singapore.
“The ministry will take the findings of the report very seriously,” she said,
adding that she would be happy to provide explanations if there were any
misunderstandings.
|
