Dear Mr. Prime Minister John Howard,
Mrs. Jenny Shipley,
Mr. Trent Lott,
Mr. Denny Hastert,
Without one single international witness.
A leading campaigner for East Timor independence, Jose Ramos-Horta,
said Indonesia was seeking to repeat the "ugly, tragic years"
of 1975-79 when some 200,000 East Timorese died in the aftermath
of Indonesia's invasion, "without one single international
witness."
"The United Nations put Indonesia on notice that
if it did not stop the killings in East Timor within 48 hours, the
world community would consider taking steps to end the bloodshed,"
U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan said in New York on Monday night
(Sep. 5, 1999), "the present chaos in East Timor cannot be
allowed to fester any longer."
On the other hand, China warned Taipei yesterday (Sep. 7, 1999)
not to hold a referendum on independence like the one in East Timor
last week, saying the result would be "very dangerous".
China lead's focus on referendum of East Timor, and fearing that
it would encourage Taiwan went ahead with such a referendum.
Nevertheless, world anger has been mounting since pro-Indonesian
militiamen, sometimes openly supported by the military, intensified
their campaign of terror against East Timorese who voted overwhelmingly
last week for independence from Indonesia. Hundreds of people have
perished in recent days, and more than 40,000 East Timorese had
fled their homes and many others were heading into West Timor ...
On the other hand, the crisis over cross-strait, after a shot period
of calm that lead some analysts to suspect President Lee Ten-hui
was mulling a back down on his controversial redefinition of cross-strait
relations, the president yesterday (Sep. 7, 1999) reaffirmed his
stance.
"For many years the PRC has called itself a central
government and Taiwan only a regional government, creating many
misunderstandings in the international arena,"
said Lee said to a group of Central America state leaders yesterday
who were attending a summit between the ROC and its Central American
allies in Taipei.
"Therefore, two months ago I pointed out that cross-strait
relations are a 'special state-to-state' relationship," said
Lee.
"This voice cannot be overlooked by the international community,"
Lee said, adding that he was only expressing an "existing
reality" that the ROC was an "independent, sovereign country."
Lee also reiterated that the nation's policy towards
mainland China has not changed. This can be interpreted to mean
that his redefinition will not be written into the ROC Constitution
nor will the National Unification Guidelines be revised.
"Under the four principles of pragmatism, parity, progress
and peace we will actively develop beneficial and mutual interactions
and reunify the nation using democratic means, " said Lee.
Lee pointed out that diplomacy and trade relations were closely
linked, and that the nation would pursue its policy of "pragmatic
diplomacy" using trade and economic relations as a basis. But
he pleaded for more international recognition for the PRC.
"For many year, the people of the ROC and its government have
hoped to rejoin the United Nations and other international organizations.
Although mainland China has oppressed and blocked this, the international
arena has gradually come to realize that the 21 million people of
the ROC have rights ... I deeply believe justice and universal rights
will prevail," Lee said.
Lee, addressing the Central American state leaders as "brothers,"
thanked them for their support and said the ROC would continue efforts
to join international organizations.
The ROC and its seven Central American allies yesterday signed
a communique at a high ranking summit that swaps continued diplomatic
backing for financial support.
The summit of Central American state leaders and President Lee
Teng-hui was the first of its kind to be held in Taiwan.
It demonstrates the ROC's intention of drumming up international
support, following continuing diplomatic isolation and Beijing's
recent fury at what it perceives as Lee's push for statehood.
The ROC will push more investment in the region and cooperate with
Central American countries in developing their economies, the communique
says, such as fostering and diversifying trade and developing tourism.
Taiwan relies on such inducements to keep diplomatic
relations with 29 mostly small, poor countries and refute mainland
China's claim that Taiwan is not a sovereign state and has no right
to diplomatic relations.
In exchange, the seven countries reiterated their "recognition
of the sovereignty of the Republic of China."
The leaders also said in the communique that "in
accordance with the principle of universality of the United Nations,
all states that meet the requirements established by the U.N. Charter
have their right to seek administration into the United Nations,"
referring to their belief in the ROC's right to enter the United
Nations.
The summit underscores the importance of Taiwan's relations with
Central America, rooted in their shared hardline anti-communism
beliefs during the Cold War but now vital to Taiwan's claim to sovereignty.
Among projects discussed at the conference were disbursement of
a US$ 240 million development fund and US$ 50 million to the Central
American Bank of Economic Integration for relending to small businesses
in the region.
The Central American countries expressed their "great
satisfaction" with advanced in cooperation between the sides,
the communique said. No solid figures on projects
were released.
The Central American leaders also expressed gratitude in the communique
for President Lee's interest for the ROC to become an extra-regional
observer of the Central American Integration System (SICA). The
Central American leaders agreed to study "appropriate ways"
to bring this about.
At a press conference after the summit, Lee refused to comment
further on cross-strait relations or constitutional reform, saying
the ROCs' domestic issues were irrelevant to the summit.
Also participating in the one-say summit were Guatemalan President
Alvaro Arzu Irigoyen, Nicaraguan President Arnoldo Aleman Lecayo,
Honduran President Carlos Roberto Flores, Salvadoran President Franciso
Guillermo Flores, Costa Rican Vice President Astrid Fishel Volio
and the deputy prime minister of Belize, John Briceno.
Vice President Jamine David Fernandez Mirabal of the Dominican
Republic, which also recognizes Taiwan, attended as an observer
and endorsed the communique.
BEIJING ---
China warned Taiwan yesterday (Sep. 7, 1999) not to hold a referendum
on independence like the one in East Timor last week, saying the
result would be "very dangerous."
"The East Timor issue and the Taiwan issue are two issues of
totally different nature and cannot be mentioned in the same breath,"
Foreign Ministry spokesman Sun Yuxi told reporters.
Sun did not elaborate. China is opposed to any move suggestive
of independence for Taiwan.
Indonesia gave its blessing to the August 30 East Timor referendum
that produced an overwhelming vote for independence. But hundreds
have been killed in recent days as pro-Indonesia militiamen went
on the rampage.
Asked what China's reaction would be if Taiwan went ahead with
such a referendum, Sun said: "This kind of action
is playing with fire. The result will be very dangerous."
But he stopped short of repeating China's longstanding threat to
invade if the island declared independence.
Sun urged Taiwan to "recognize the situation and walk the
road of peaceful reunification and 'one country, two systems'."
Beijing wants Taipei to reunify peacefully under the "one
country, two systems" formula under which Hong Kong reverted
to Chinese rule in 1997 and was promised a high degree of autonomy.
Ties between Beijing and Taipei have soured since Taiwan President
Lee Teng-hui declared in July that bilateral ties should be on a
"special state-to-state" basis.
China saw Lee's declaration as an abandonment of the "one
China" policy that kept the peace for decades and as a "dangerous"
lurch towards statehood.
China's Communist Party flagship newspaper, the People's Daily,
said in a front page commentary yesterday the mainland would reunify
with Taiwan one day no matter what the cost.
"No matter how grim the situation is, no matter
how tortuous the road is, the Chinese government and the Chinese
people will surmount all difficulties and ultimately complete the
great cause of reunifying the motherland," it said.
East Timor's bid for autonomy should be met with full respect,
the foreign ministry said yesterday (Sep. 4, 1999), but it denied
any relevance of the violence-plagued province to cross-strait relations.
"As a member of the international community, we respect the
people's decision," Foreign Ministry Spokesman Henry Chen told
the Taiwan News.
But Chen doubted if the East Timor referendum could lend any experience
to Taiwan, which has recently hit heightened tensions since President
Lee Teng-hui proposed on July 9 to have special state-to-state ties
with China.
"The East Timorese people could come to the ballot booth to
decide their country's future because the Indonesian government
allowed it," Chen said. "This is a the essential factor."
"There is simply no relevance between the direct vote and
our situation, for two reasons. First, we have been a sovereign
state since the very beginning. Second, China," he said.
"Referendum - needless to say, is out of question,"
Chen said.
"Asked if Taiwan would consider building diplomatic ties with
East Timor, Chen said it is too early to discuss. "We will
wait until the situation calms down."
Democratic Progressive Party legislator Alice Wang, a member of
the Legislature's foreign affairs committee, espoused a different
outlook.
"This is a very good example of how democracy
works," she said.
Milton Yeh, professor at National Chi' Nan University's Southeast
Asian Studies Graduate School, said there was simply no similarity
between the East Timor's case and Taiwan's situation right now.
"East Timor was allowed by the Indonesian government to hold
a public vote, and it has been endorsed by dozens of foreign countries,"
Yeh said.
"But in our case, none of the nations the world over would
like to see strained ties between Taiwan and China, regardless of
the reason."
In our view, the real purpose of President Lee's statement
is to achieve equal political status for fair negotiation in the
near future.