China's Russia on July 15, 2004

Watch for China's split with Russia

By Paul Lin

US National Security Adviser Condoleezza Rice recently visited Japan, China and South Korea. The tour was probably related to US President George W. Bush's preparations for the presidential election campaign.

The US has invited Chinese President Hu Jintao to the US, partly to find out where China draws the line on the Taiwan issue, and partly to show voters the importance the administration attaches to the US-China relationship.

Of the two US presidential candidates, China clearly prefers the presumptive Democratic candidate, Senator John Kerry, who has said that he wants to solve the Taiwan issue using the "one country, two systems" model to Bush, who is militarily aggressive and quite friendly towards Taiwan. China will therefore raise the price for accepting Bush's invitation, since it doesn't want to improve Bush's chances during the election campaign. Rice's visit to China was therefore a difficult task. If Hu visits the US next month, it will attract a lot of attention. Apart from affecting the China-US relationship, such a visit will also have an effect on Beijing's internal power struggles.

There is also an aspect to this interaction between China and the US that is positive to the US. Changes negative to China have occurred in the international strategic situation. Namely, China's relationships with neighboring states have become strained. Although not too obvious as yet, it can be said with near-certainty that these tensions will intensify in the future. They are thus important changes, and most important among them are the changes in China's relationships with Russia and Japan.

There are two aspects to the changes in the China-Russia relationship. The first aspect was embodied by the three-week-long military exercise held in Russia's far east last month. It was the nation's biggest military exercise in the 15 years since the collapse of the Soviet Union, and it was held in the vicinity of Dongning, Heilongjiang Province, and Chunhua, Jilin Province. These two cities are situated close to Vladivostok, the largest port in Russia's far east, and Nakhodka, which will be the end point on the pipeline that will be built to transport Russian oil to Japan.

There is also another oil-related change: the official Russian announcement that it has reversed course on the construction of the pipeline from Angarsk in Russia to Daqing in China, which Russia originally had agreed to. Although the Angarsk-Nakhodka pipeline suggested by Japan will not be built, there will be a pipeline from Taishet to Nakhodka, still clearly biased towards Japan. Observers are now trying to assess what retributive measures China will adopt towards Russia.

Over the past dozen years or so, Russia has sold large quantities of advanced weapons to China, and former president Jiang Zemin has confirmed treaties signed in the19th century and in which China ceded a total of 3 million km2 of its territory to Russia, but without succeeding in winning back the friendship of "Big Brother" Russia.

Russia has both ambitions and worries, thinking that once China grows strong, it may demand the return of the land included in those treaties. Furthermore, a few million Chinese people have already moved into these sparsely populated areas, and could in the future demand self determination. Maybe this is how the Washington Times, in a recent report, came to the conclusion that Russia and the US are cooperating to build the submarines to be sold to Taiwan. Some observers also think that Russia may use a possible Chinese attack on Taiwan as an opportunity to attack China from behind.

The old slogan of the Chinese Communist Party that "the Russian revisionists are still trying to destroy us" anticipated the fact that the Soviet Union's tanks could roll directly into the Chinese capital through Mongolia. This was also the reason that Mao Zedong changed his policy of "overthrowing US imperialism" into a policy of friendship with the US.

Japan has also tried hard to destroy China in the past, but the greatest threat has instead been Russia, which also is the nation to which China has ceded the largest part of its territory. After Jiang came to power, he changed Mao and Deng Xiaoping's policies in favor of anti-American nationalism, ignoring the Russian threat.

In order to cover up the cracks in the China-Russia relationship, the vice chairman of the Central Military Commission, Guo Boxiong, recently visited Moscow. On July 6, he met with Russian Defense Minister Sergei Ivanov. Unexpectedly, the two sides signed a memorandum on holding joint military exercises, something which will only make the problems more obvious. Russia specialist Rice will have her own way of widening these cracks.

Paul Lin is a commentator based in New York.

China dissatisfied after Rice's visit

By Charles Snyder
STAFF REPORTER , IN WASHINGTON
 

China expressed unhappiness with the results of last week's visit by US National Security Advisor Condoleezza Rice to Beijing, demanding the US stop selling advanced arms to Taiwan, and telling Washington that "it's time to honor its commitments" to a "one China" policy.

The press spokesman of the Chinese embassy in Washington, Sun Weide, made the comments in a rare press conference on Tuesday in response to the Rice meeting.

In the press conference, which was open to both the Taiwanese and international press corps, Sun insisted that any resumption of cross-strait dialogue should be based on Beijing's "one China" principle, and warned that any increase in tensions over Taiwan between China and the US could set back bilateral relations.

He also indicated that China would not look favorably on any efforts by Washington to play a greater role in bringing Beijing and Taipei together for resumed cross-strait dialogue.

"Taiwan is part of China," he said, "so the Chinese can solve their problems by themselves," Sun said.

During her talks with former Chinese president Jiang Zemin in Beijing, Rice suggested that China open a dialogue with President Chen Shui-bian without insisting on a "one China" principle as a precondition, according to a report in The New York Times.

Sun clearly rejected that idea.

"The `one China' principle is very important," he said. "If Taiwan accepts the `one China' principle, there will be great prospects for cross-strait relations."

Sun indicated that while Rice's visit was aimed at advancing Beijing-Washington relations, in terms of the Taiwan issue, the trip did not accomplish that goal.

"We are gravely concerned over the recent US moves on the Taiwan questions," Sun said in an opening statement.

Repeating the so-called "three stops" that Foreign Minister Li Zhaoxing communicated to Rice, Sun said, "We strongly urge the US side to stop selling advanced arms to Taiwan and cut the military links between the US and Taiwan, stop any official exchanges with Taiwan authorities, stop supporting Taiwan to join the international organizations where statehood is required."

"Only in this way can the stable development of the China-US relations as well as the peace and stability across the Taiwan Strait be guaranteed," Sun said.

During the talks between Rice and Chinese leaders, the Chinese "emphasized the importance of the Taiwan issue in US-China relations," Sun said. "This cannot be overemphasized."

Sun stressed that the issue of Taiwan dominated the discussion.

"During the talks, we said again and again that the Taiwan issue bears on China's national sovereignty and territorial integrity, and it is always the most important and sensitive issue in China-US relations," Sun said.