20100826 US moving forward with radar sales

US moving forward with radar sales

POLICY SHIFT?: The head of the US-Taiwan Business Council said the move seems to indicate that the Obama administration is lifting its ‘hold’ on arms sales to Taiwan

By William Lowther
STAFF REPORTER , WASHINGTON
Thursday, Aug 26, 2010, Page 1

The US State Department has notified Congress that it is going ahead with three arms sales programs to Taiwan — after holding them up for more than six months.

While the programs are not huge — they involve radar upgrades for Indigenous Defense Fighters (IDF) — the move could be significant in that it shows US President Barack Obama standing up to China and supporting Taiwan despite Beijing’s protests.

Rupert Hammond-Chambers, president of the US-Taiwan Business Council, said the move signaled an “apparent change in policy.”

According to the council, after the White House released several programs from former US president George W. Bush’s administration for congressional notification in January, a decision was made to submit no further notifications for the year.

Thus the latest congressional notification would seem to indicate that the “hold” on arms sales to Taiwan has been lifted by the Obama administration.

The decision to lift the “hold” seems to have been made at about the same time that it was decided to release a long-delayed Pentagon report on the Chinese military that revealed a continuing and secretive buildup by Beijing with the balance of power across the Taiwan Strait leaning substantially in China’s favor.

The Pentagon report also noted China’s lack of cooperation with the US on military affairs.

China has strongly objected to all US arms sales to Taiwan and in the hope of reducing tensions with Beijing, Washington has exercised extreme caution.

However, as the Washington Post recently said in a front-page story: “The Obama administration has adopted a tougher tone with China.”

The newspaper said the US had rejected China’s claims to sovereignty over the whole South China Sea; rebuffed Chinese demands that the US military end its long-time policy of conducting military exercises in the Yellow Sea; and was putting new pressure on Beijing not to increase its energy investments in Iran as Western firms leave.

US officials told the Post that the moves were part of a broader strategy to acknowledge China’s emergence as a world power, but to also “lay down markers when China’s behavior infringes on US interests.”

The council said the latest military sales were a “small move to end Taiwan arms freezes.”

It said the recent policy under both the Bush and Obama administrations — freezing Taiwan arms sales notifications and then releasing them as packages — has had the “inverse effect of its apparent intent.”

“By creating multi-billion dollar packages that capture headlines, the policy has increased Chinese ire at such sales rather than reducing it,” the council said.

“China has rightly deduced that the process is vulnerable to external pressure, and recently applied such pressure by threatening sanctions against American companies and by denying entry to China for US Secretary of Defense Robert Gates,” the council said.

China, the council says, was employing a carrot-and-stick strategy with Taiwan, offering significant economic incentives with the recently signed Economic Cooperation Framework Agreement (ECFA) while continuing military modernization and expanding the material threat represented by the People’s Liberation Army (PLA).

"This strategy compels a response from both Taiwan and the United States,” the council said. “Allowing China’s military threat to go unmet threatens any hope of long-term success in reducing cross-strait tensions.”

“Both the US and Taiwan must determine which actions to take in support of Taiwan’s national security, without caving to pressure from China. Regularizing the Taiwan arms sales process will in the long term make support for Taiwan’s defense needs more transparent and stable,” it said.

“The US Department of Defense is due to submit to Congress a second report by the end of 2010 examining the current balance of airpower in the Taiwan Strait and making recommendations for US action,” Hammond-Chambers said. “This will include consideration of the impact of replacement fighters for Taiwan’s aging air force. F-16s are the only platform under consideration for Taiwan, but the F-16 manufacturing line will begin to wind down in July of 2011. This leaves a narrow 10-month window for a decision on making the requested 66 F-16s available to Taiwan.”

“Taiwan is also looking to upgrade its current fleet of 145 F-16s, and in the absence of political obstruction a congressional notification is due for this program some time in the winter of 2010-2011,” he said.

The Chinese believe Taiwan should be denied access to replacement fighters for their aging F-5s and Mirage-2000s, recognizing the serious detrimental effect such a denial would have on Taiwan’s military readiness, he said.

A senior White House source refused to comment on the issue.