|
Government stewed over tycoon’s visit
CONTROVERSY:An official said government agencies had
agonized over Chen Guangbiao’s trip, while a Chinese dissident urged the public
to be more positive
By Ko Shu-ling / Staff reporter
A woman counts the banknotes she received from
the Chinese tycoon and philanthropist Chen Guangbiao in Hsinchu yesterday.
Photo: Liu Hsin-de, Taipei Times
A Mainland Affairs Council (MAC) official yesterday said that government
agencies had struggled to decide whether to approve Chinese tycoon and
philanthropist Chen Guangbiao’s (陳光標) visit to Taiwan, during which he is
expected to make substantial donations to disadvantaged families.
MAC Deputy Minister Liu Te-shun (劉德勳) said the government agencies handling
Chen’s case agonized over the decision as they were caught between polarized
public opinion on the visit.
“It is a good thing to bring a little warmth in the chill of winter, but due to
Chen’s particular style, the low-income families [who receive money] are faced
with a challenge,” Liu said, apparently referring to Chen’s taste for heavily
publicized philanthropic trips around China.
In one donation stunt in China, he piled up a “wall of banknotes,” before giving
them away.
However, Liu said that he thought Taiwanese society was mature enough to face
the issue rationally.
Liu added that TV interviews were not on Chen’s itinerary when the application
was approved by the National Immigration Agency (NIA) on Tuesday.
After Chen changed his itinerary and gave an interview to a TV station
yesterday, Liu said he would have to check with the NIA to better understand the
situation regarding Chen’s visa.
If politics are involved in the charity work, “it then should be renounced,” Liu
added.
Earlier yesterday at a separate setting, exiled Chinese dissident Wuer Kaixi
(吾爾開希) said Taiwanese should be more tolerant and look at Chen’s benevolent act
with a more positive attitude.
“If he wants to hand out money, respect and thank him. Even if the way he does
it is different from what we expect, we also should respect him, even though we
know we would never do it in that way,” he said. “What it comes down to is how
the people who receive the money feel because it is more important than how we
feel. They might think it is a good thing.”
While some have criticized Chen’s handouts as a “united front” tactic, Wuer
Kaixi said the term had been abused.
“Taiwan does not need to be so afraid of the united front tactics of the Chinese
Communist Party [CCP],” he said. “Taiwanese should not worry that people with
low moral values will have any sway on those with high moral values.”
The way that Chen hands out the money in such a high-profile manner reflects the
yawning chasm between the two sides of the Taiwan Strait in terms of moral
values, Wuer Kaixi said.
“Many of my friends who have visited Beijing and Shanghai tell me there are a
lot more skyscrapers there,” he said. “I usually laugh and tell them that
China’s high efficiency is based on the sacrifices of its own people. Taiwan is
not as efficient because it fully respects individual rights and that is nothing
to be ashamed of.”
Asked whether the government should ask Chen to keep a low profile during his
visit, Wuer Kaixi said he did not think it was necessary, as Taiwanese society
is tolerant, open and diverse.
“Taiwan should not ask a Chinese philanthropist to do what they want him to do
because that is something the CCP would do to a Taiwanese philanthropist,” he
said. “That is the difference between Taiwan and China.”
Wuer Kaixi said it would be nice if it were true that Chen was planning to
change the way he gives out the money, but he said he hoped such a change would
be made because Chen was touched by Taiwanese people rather than because of
pressure exerted by legislators in the opposition parties.
“I think it would be better if opposition legislators were more tolerant of
benevolent acts, even if they have a different position and ideology about a
particular matter,” he said.
|
