|
Ma ignoring public fears of nuclear
catastrophe
By Lu Shih-hsiang 盧世祥
The massive earthquake and ensuing tsunami that struck Japan on March 11, which
led to the crisis at the Fukushima Dai-ichi nuclear power plant, have triggered
a debate on nuclear energy in Taiwan. The response of President Ma Ying-jeou’s
(馬英九) government echoes the way it defends its China policy — underestimating
the risk and telling the public that it need not worry because everything will
be just fine.
Taiwan’s nuclear power plants are built near faults and volcanoes, and the three
operational plants are already getting old. According to the March 19 edition of
the Wall Street Journal, those three plants and the fourth one, which is still
under construction, are among the most risk-prone in the world.
A responsible government would immediately stop operations at the three working
plants to allow for safety inpsections, and then seriously consider scrapping
the fourth one. It would also make greater efforts to expand alternative energy
resources, improve energy efficiency and implement the existing “nuclear-free
county” clause in the Basic Environment Act (環境基本法).
However, that is not what this government has in mind. It would have us believe
that Taiwan’s nuclear power plants are as safe as houses. It raises the specter
of economic collapse if the country were to abandon nuclear energy, while citing
selective statistics to mislead the public.
While failing to set the public’s mind at rest, the government is also wasting a
good opportunity to work out the best combination of energy resources for the
nation.
Between the two extremes of scrapping nuclear power and further developing it,
there are other options, such as gradual plant closures and slowly reducing our
dependence on nuclear energy.
The government’s China policy also poses a grave threat for Taiwan. In a sense,
this threat is even more serious, because Taiwan cannot decide the outcome
alone. China is using a carrot-and-stick strategy to work toward the goal of
annexing Taiwan.
However, the Ma administration seems to believe that if Taiwan acts obsequiously
and pleases China by promoting a “diplomatic truce” and scrapping its defenses,
the result will be peace and economic bonuses. Under the previous administration
of president Chen Shui-bian (陳水扁), the Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) used its
majority in the legislature to oppose procurements of US arms.
Since taking office in 2008, Ma has repeatedly bragged about the “peace bonuses”
of his China policy. He wants the public to share in his self--assurance, while
the country unwittingly walks further and further into danger.
As to assessing the risks of its current China policy and working out how to
respond if something goes wrong, the government has nothing to offer.
Just as we protect our own homes, we have to stand together in defense of our
homeland.
Over the past three years, the government has narrowed Taiwan’s prospects by
replacing “internationalization” with “sinicization.” The more Taiwan becomes
integrated with China, the harder it gets to pull out.
The government is doing something similar with regard to nuclear power,
expecting the public to accept it regardless of the risks and refusing to
reconsider its nuclear energy policy.
The only assurance Ma can offer is: “With me in charge, your heart can be at
ease.”
Unfortunately, given this administration’s record of incompetence, there can be
few people who feel “at ease” as long as Ma remains in office.
Lu Shih-hsiang is an adviser to the Taipei Times.
TRANSLATED BY EDDY CHANG
|
