|
Retrial finds A-bian
not guilty of graft
JUSTICE DELAYED: The former president and first
lady were overjoyed by the ruling, although they were handed extra jail time as
a result of the new verdict
By Chris Wand / Staff Reporter
Former president Chen Shui-bian
waves as he arrives at the Taiwan High Court in Taipei yesterday.
Photo: AFP
Supporters of former president
Chen Shui-bian hold up signs and call for his release outside the Taiwan High
Court in Taipei City yesterday. The court rescinded previous rulings and found
Chen and former first lady Wu Shu-jen not guilty of corruption in the retrial of
the state affairs fund case.
Photo: Liu Hsin-de, Taipei Times
The Taiwan High Court yesterday rescinded
previous rulings and found former president Chen Shui-bian (陳水扁) and former
first lady Wu Shu-jen (吳淑珍) not guilty of corruption, in a retrial of their
state affairs fund case.
However, it upheld Chen’s previous conviction for his role in the use of
fraudulent receipts to obtain reimbursement for spending from the state affairs
fund. On that charge, Chen was given an additional 20-month prison sentence that
was cut to 10 months in accordance with a commutation statute.
The court also upheld Chen’s conviction for his role in a money laundering case
that concerned a land deal in Taoyuan County’s Longtan (龍潭) and sentenced him to
another two years in prison.
The new ruling leaves Chen, who is serving a 17.5-year sentence on corruption
charges, with an additional two years and eight months in prison and a fine of
NT$3 million (US$103,400).
Wu, while acquitted on charges relating to the embezzlement of money from the
state affairs fund, was given a 20-month sentence for forgery in the matter of
the fraudulent receipts. This sentence was also cut to 10 months in accordance
with a commutation statute.
In the money laundering case, Wu was sentenced to two years in prison. She was
also given another sentence of nine years in prison for her involvement in a
bribery case related to the construction of the Nangang Exhibition Hall. The
court ruled that Wu should be jailed for 11 years and six months, in addition to
paying a fine of NT$22 million and being stripped of her civic rights for five
years.
Last November, the Supreme Court sentenced Chen and Wu to 17.5 years in prison
for involvement in the Longtan case and the appointment of Diana Chen (陳敏薰) as
the chairperson of the Taipei Financial Center Corp (台北金融大樓公司).
The court at the time ordered a retrial of the state affairs fund embezzlement,
money laundering and Nangang Exhibition Hall cases.
Taiwan High Court spokesman Chen Ching-chiao (陳晴教) yesterday said the court
acquitted Chen of corruption in the state affairs fund case because he had spent
more than the funds he received during his terms in office and spent all of the
money on state affairs, including 21 secret diplomacy programs and bonuses to
his staff.
Chen’s lawyer, Shih Yi-lin (石宜琳), said Chen has expressed gratitude about the
ruling as well as regret over the sloppiness of the workings of state apparatus
in his hasty detainment.
“We would like to think today’s verdict is related to the decriminalization of
personal use of the ‘special affairs funds,’ because what the state affairs
funds mean to the president is actually what the special affairs funds mean to
different levels of government officials,” Shih said.
Personal use of the special affairs funds was decriminalized in May, ending a
string of embezzlement cases against dozens of officials.
In its representation, Chen’s legal team also cited President Ma Ying-jeou’s
(馬英九) “reservoir theory,” which Ma used to defend his use of the special funds
during his stint as Taipei mayor and which successfully saw Ma through his own
embezzlement case.
While Shih said Chen would decide whether to appeal the money-laundering and
forgery charges after reviewing the written ruling, the supreme prosecutors’
office’s Special Investigation Division said it would appeal the ruling.
Commenting on the ruling, Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) Chairperson and
presidential candidate Tsai Ing-wen (蔡英文) said the state affairs funds case
“contains historical factors” which the DPP believes the judiciary should take
into account, while upholding fairness, independence and respect for human
rights during the legal process.
Both the Presidential Office and Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) spokesperson
Lai Su-ju (賴素如) said they respected the court’s decision. KMT Legislator Chiu Yi
(邱毅), on the other hand, said he found the ruling shocking and slammed the
judges “for selling their souls to the devil.”
The court also sentenced Chen’s son, Chen Chih-chung (陳致中) and daughter-in-law,
Huang Jui-ching (黃睿靚), to 14 months and 12 months respectively for their roles
in the money-laundering case. Huang was given four-years’ probation.
Chen Chih-chung said he was happy his father had been found innocent, but could
not accept the verdict handed down to him and would appeal.
Additional reporting by CNA
|
