Public health No. 1
priority, DPP says
BEEF BALLYHOO: The DPP said the Ma
administration was ready to sacrifice people¡¦s health to assuage the US with its
¡¥obvious¡¦ intention to lift the ban on ractopamine
By Shih Hsiu-chuan and Chris Wang / Staff Reporters
Members of various civic groups
gather in front of the American Institute in Taiwan in Taipei yesterday to
protest talk of lifting the ban on US beef containing the additive ractopamine.
Photo: Fang Pin-chao, Taipei Times
Members of civic groups and
Democratic Progressive Party legislators hold a press conference demanding more
transparency in the government¡¦s closed-door discussions on ractopamine residues
in US beef imports.
Photo: CNA
A small group of protesters gathered
outside the American Institute in Taiwan (AIT) in Taipei yesterday, calling on
the US not to press Taiwan on beef imports, while opposition lawmakers and heads
of local governments called on the administration of President Ma Ying-jeou
(°¨^¤E) to make public health its No. 1 priority.
Chanting slogans, displaying posters and performing a skit intended to show that
imports of US meat products containing the feed additive ractopamine would
endanger public health, about 30 protesters, led by Labor Rights Association
executive director Wang Chuan-ping (¤ý®SµÓ), chanted: ¡§Oppose the US imposing drugs
on Taiwan,¡¨ ¡§Defend the people¡¦s right to health,¡¨ ¡§Protest against the US over
internal interference¡¨ and ¡§Protect the local livestock industry.¡¨
The protest lasted for about 50 minutes and ended when Joseph Parker, an AIT
official, came out of the building to receive the protesters¡¦ written statement.
Separately, Yang Guan-chang (·¨«a³¹), director of the nationwide association of hog
farmers ¡X the Republic of China Swine Association ¡X said his group would stage
protests if the government lifts the import ban.
¡§We will set up an emergency response team, which will stay on high alert on
ractopamine policy, and we will organize a rally immediately¡¨ once a decision is
made, Yang said.
Meanwhile, Yilan County Commissioner Lin Tsung-hsien (ªLÁo½å) of the Democratic
Progressive Party (DPP) said the county government would establish rules at
local government level to prohibit the sale of meat products containing
ractopamine if a public hearing scheduled to be held next month reaches a
consensus.
The heads of five local governments headed by the DPP in the south of the nation
¡X Yunlin County, Chiayi County, Greater Tainan, Greater Kaohsiung and Pingtung
County ¡X issued a statement urging the Ma administration to make food safety and
public health the top priority.
The DPP said the Ma administration was ready to sacrifice people¡¦s health to
assuage the US with its ¡§obvious¡¨ intention to lift the ban on ractopamine.
One of the conclusions reached in the second inter-ministerial meeting on US
beef on Tuesday was that ractopamine poses no health concerns unless 500kg of
meat containing the drug is consumed, which is ¡§ridiculous,¡¨ DPP caucus whip Pan
Men-an (¼ï©s¦w) told a press conference.
The DPP legislative caucus was disappointed by the meeting, as the government is
to make a final decision based on opinions of only 10 experts, DPP Legislator
Chen Ting-fei (³¯«F¦m) said.
The meeting cited only information provided by the US government, which has
endorsed the safety of ractopamine, despite reports by the Council of
Agriculture, the European Food Safety Authority, the University of Iowa and
Purdue University that suggested a negative impact from the use of ractopamine,
she said.
¡§If the Ma administration eventually lifts the restriction, it will be a
betrayal of Ma¡¦s campaign pledge,¡¨ DPP Legislator Huang Wei-cher (¶À°¶õ) said,
adding that Ma expressed his opposition to ractopamine in 2007, while vice
president-elect Wu Den-yih (§d´°¸q) said in March last year as premier that ¡§Taiwan
welcomes imported US beef not containing ractopamine.¡¨
The Taiwan Solidarity Union (TSU) said it is also strongly opposed to loosening
restrictions on ractopamine in meat products and it gave the premier 48 hours to
make a pledge not to allow meat imports containing the feed additive.
If Premier Sean Chen fails to do so, TSU caucus whip Hsu Chung-hsin (³\©¾«H) said
the party¡¦s three legislators would boycott the premier¡¦s report to the
legislature tomorrow when the new session begins.
The lifting of the restrictions on US beef appeared to be imminent following
Ma¡¦s comments after his meeting with AIT Chairman Raymond Burghardt and recent
Cabinet meetings, Hsu said.
Despite Ma reiterating that there is no timetable or a set position on the
issue, Hsu said the TSU suspects that Ma forged ¡§secret deals¡¨ with the US
during his re-election campaign.
According to a pair of public opinion polls conducted by TVBS on Feb. 10 and
Feb. 13, 78 percent of respondents are opposed to US beef or pork imports
containing ractopamine, TSU Legislator Huang Wen-ling (¶À¤å¬Â) said.
Civic groups criticized the transparency of the inter-ministerial meeting at
another press conference yesterday, while announcing a ¡§three noes¡¨ initiative
against US beef imports.
The alliance said it would not recognize the results of the meeting; that its
members would not consume US beef products containing ractopamine; and that it
would not cease to protest.
The AIT yesterday reiterated its wish that the Ma administration take a
¡§scientific¡¨ approach when handling the issue of whether to allow imports of US
meat products containing ractopamine.
¡§Food safety standards should be based on scientific evidence. Scientific
evidence has attested to the safety of US beef with ractopamine residues,¡¨ AIT
spokesperson Christopher Kavanagh told reporters.
US beef is also proven safe because consumers in the US, Japan, South Korea and
many other countries have consumed US beef ¡§millions of times¡¨ and there have
been no health problems associated with eating US beef, he said.
Kavanagh made the remarks when asked by reporters about a statement issued on
Tuesday that disproved what the AIT called ¡§misinformation¡¨ widely reported by
the media that questions the safety of ractopamine-fed livestock.
Twenty-seven countries have determined that meat from animals fed ractopamine, a
feed additive used to improve lean-meat production in livestock, is safe for
human consumption. However, strong opposition, primarily from the EU and China,
meant that the Codex Alimentarius Commission, the international food standards
body, is one step short of final approval of draft maximum residue levels.
The draft levels were recommended by the Joint Expert Committee on Food
Additives, under the UN Food and Agriculture Organization and the WHO.
Media reports often fail to recognize that both the EU and China may have their
own ¡§non-scientific reasons¡¨ for refusing to import meat from ractopamine-fed
livestock when their cases are cited as examples that cast doubt on the safety
of ractopamine, the AIT said.
In 1996, the EU implemented a ban on beta-agonists, the class of drug to which
ractopamine belongs, long before ractopamine was even introduced to the market,
and it did not conduct any studies on ractopamine prior to adding it to its list
of already-banned beta-agonists, the AIT said.
The European Food Safety Authority subsequently conducted a review of existing
research on ractopamine in 2009 that focused on scientific and evidence-based
studies, but the review actually offered no new research, the AIT said.
¡§If you ban something before you even test it, it¡¦s not a scientific approach.
Food safety standards should be established based on science, on what is safe
for [human consumption] and what is the best approach for agriculture.
Otherwise, what do you use for the standards?¡¨ Kavanagh said by telephone.
In the case of China, Kavanagh said Beijing also had its own ¡§non-scientific
reasons¡¨ for refusing to import meat products containing ractopamine, but he did
not elaborate.
|