|
Why did coast guard
escort PRC flag-bearer?
By Chiang Huang-chih «¸¬Ó¦À
On July 4, the Taiwan-registered recreational fishing boat Quanjiafu (¥þ®aºÖ)
sailed into seas surrounding the disputed Diaoyutai Islands (³¨³½¥x), flying the
five-star red flag of the People¡¦s Republic of China (PRC).
Article 7 of the Ships Act (²î²íªk) stipulates that ships registered in the
Republic of China (ROC), ie, Taiwan, are not allowed to fly a non-ROC flag,
while Article 94 of the same law states that the shipping administration
authority will impose a fine of between NT$6,000 and NT$60,000 on the owner,
master or steerer of any ship that violates this provision.
When Japan Coast Guard boats approached the Quanjiafu, one of the people on
board the Taiwanese boat came out and waved a PRC flag. This was surely a
violation of the aforementioned law, because ¡§flying a flag¡¨ does not only mean
raising it on a ship¡¦s mast, but also painting it on the sides of the ship,
hanging it from the cabin and so on. That is how the term is understood around
the world.
Having violated the rule that ROC ships should not fly non-ROC flags, the ship¡¦s
owner or master should face a fine, so why has our government done nothing about
it?
Another point is that, according to the Coast Guard Authority¡¦s (CGA) standard
operating procedure for fishery protection, when Japanese vessels interfere with
Taiwanese fishing vessels within the temporary law enforcement line, the
government will dispatch ships to escort them and provide assistance.
Accordingly, the CGA maintains boats on patrol on Taiwan¡¦s side of the temporary
law enforcement line at all times and in all weather. To ensure that patrol
boats can respond quickly to any incident, one patrol boat takes over from
another at the scene, rather than first returning to port.
However, the CGA never dispatches multiple patrol boats to escort a particular
fishing boat, follow its every move and guard it closely. That is because lots
of fishing boats go fishing in waters northwest of Taiwan and close to the
Diaoyutai Islands. It would be impossible for Taiwan to escort every fishing
boat, and even if it were possible, it would be a waste of resources.
However, on this occasion, as soon as the Quanjiafu left port, and before it had
met with any interference, five patrol boats arrived to escort it all the way.
Providing a Taiwanese boat flying the Chinese five-star flag with such an
exclusive ¡§five-star¡¨ escort service is not at all in line with the government¡¦s
standard operating procedure, or with the usual practice established over many
years.
The government should explain which department or officials made such a peculiar
decision, and why. Otherwise, any fishing boat that heads into waters northeast
of Taiwan will be able to cite the recent incident as a precedent and demand
that the authorities send out patrol boats to protect it.
What will be left of our authorities¡¦ prestige if they fail to handle this
matter properly? The government is duty-bound to investigate the incident and
give the public a credible explanation.
Chiang Huang-chih is a law professor at National Taiwan University.
Translated by Julian Clegg
|
