DPP sends mixed
signals on NHI proposal
UNHEALTHY DEBATE: A suggestion that Chinese
students be eligible for the National Health Insurance has been criticized as
inappropriate, and praised for good intentions
By Chris Wang and Mo Yan-chih / Staff reporters
A proposal by Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) Legislator Wu Ping-jui (§dªÃèû) to
include Chinese students in the National Health Insurance (NHI) program
yesterday continued to draw mixed reactions from party members, while the
Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) accused the DPP of prevarication.
The initiative, which Wu said was submitted out of humanitarian concerns instead
of political motives, backfired in the media, with most DPP members expressing
reservations about the proposal.
Wu apologized for his ¡§recklessness¡¨ and the ¡§inappropriate timing¡¨ after many
DPP supporters and politicians expressed opposition in recent days, leading to
the proposal¡¦s withdrawal.
DPP Chairman Su Tseng-chang (Ĭs©÷), who at first described the proposal as Wu¡¦s
¡§personal opinion,¡¨ stepped up the rhetoric on Monday, saying the initiative was
¡§inappropriate and rushed.¡¨
DPP caucus chief secretary Tsai Chi-chang (½²¨ä©÷) told a press conference that
most DPP lawmakers were ¡§reserved¡¨ about the proposal, despite their position
that every proposal should be respected.
¡§Most lawmakers think the NHI is more of a social welfare and less of an
insurance system, which is why it has suffered great financial loss and why they
[critics] question whether coverage should be expanded,¡¨ Tsai said.
However, DPP legislators Kuan Bi-ling (ºÞºÑ¬Â) and Huang Wei-cher (¶À°¶õ) lauded Wu
for having ¡§good intentions¡¨ and said the DPP should encourage discussion and
creativity in public policy formulation, while Wang Dan (¤ý¤¦), a Chinese
dissident now teaching at National Tsing Hua University, said he supported the
initiative as a teacher and as a Chinese.
¡§The proposal would attract more Chinese students to study in Taiwan, which
would help promote democracy in China. By making a little sacrifice, Taiwan
would be able to create a positive image among the Chinese people.
Strategically, I think that would be a good option for Taiwan,¡¨ Wang said.
¡§From the perspective of human rights, I don¡¦t see why Chinese students cannot
enjoy the same rights as other foreign students,¡¨ said Chang Tieh-chih (±iÅK§Ó), a
political commentator.
The Taiwan Solidarity Union (TSU), which has a more rigid policy on China,
opposed the initiative and said state-to-state relations between Taiwan and
China should be reaffirmed before such a measure could be adopted.
TSU Legislator Huang Wen-ling (¶À¤å¬Â) said that China has never renounced its
territorial ambition on Taiwan and Taiwan should take care of its nationals
first.
Meanwhile, the KMT accused the DPP of being ¡§capricious¡¨ in its cross-strait
policies and said the DPP¡¦s decision to withdraw the proposal revealed its
unwillingness to come to a better understanding with China, as it claims it is
trying to do.
¡§Chairman Su was capricious about the proposal. It is obvious that the DPP¡¦s
cross-strait policies are opportunistic and lack context,¡¨ KMT spokesperson Ma
Wei-kuo (°¨Þ³°ê) said.
She questioned the DPP¡¦s about-face on the issue, saying the party at first made
the proposal to address human rights, but then withdrew the proposal because DPP
supporters opposed it.
¡§Chairman Su said the DPP reinstated the Chinese Affairs Department in order to
understand China, but the DPP has once again been kidnapped by political
ideology. We still don¡¦t know the direction the DPP is heading in terms of
cross-strait policies,¡¨ she said.
If the DPP plans to make adjustments to its cross-strait policies, it should not
only discuss the inclusion of Chinese students in the health insurance program,
but develop a more comprehensive policy on Chinese students, she said.
|