APEC Web
site removes data
BACKTRACK: MOFA said Taiwan
was not the only country to have its data removed from the Web site, while the
Presidential Office hailed the ‘breakthrough’ in relations
By Ko Shu-ling And
Jenny W. Hsu
STAFF REPORTERS
Thursday, Nov 20, 2008, Page 3
The Presidential Office yesterday downplayed the removal of President Ma Ying-jeou’s
(馬英九) photograph and information from the APEC Web site, saying they were happy
about the “breakthrough” the country made this year.
Presidential Office Spokesman Wang Yu-chi (王郁琦) called the “breakthrough” the
“biggest” since APEC was established 17 years ago.
“It serves the interests of Taiwan if we continue to make progress,” he said.
Ma on Tuesday acknowledged the organizer of this year’s APEC summit for using
his photograph and referring to him as “president” on the Web site and official
documents, saying it indicated his more conciliatory cross-strait policies were
working.
It marked the first time that the country’s president was introduced in an APEC
document and the first time since Taiwan became an APEC member economy in 1991
that a host country published a picture of a Taiwanese president on the Web
site.
Ma’s photograph and other information, however, were later removed from the Web
site. Critics suspected China of interfering in the matter.
Since Taiwan and China joined APEC in 1991, Beijing has blocked Taipei’s
presidents and foreign ministers from attending the group’s forums, citing a
memorandum of understanding signed with China and Hong Kong before Taipei joined
the group under the name “Chinese Taipei.” Under this memorandum, the three
economies entered the organization as a single economic entity.
Beijing’s backroom bullying over Taiwan’s participation at APEC reached a climax
in 2001, when the meeting was held in Shanghai, and Beijing blocked Taiwan from
attending the leaders meeting.
The Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MOFA) said yesterday that Taiwan’s standing in
APEC remained solid, adding that Taiwan was not the only country whose profile
was erased from the APEC Web site.
“According to our understanding,” said Director-General of the Department of
International Organizations Paul Chang (章文樑), “the entire section that
introduces all the heads of member economies was completely taken down.”
He added that Taiwan was not singled out and the public should not read too much
into the situation.
Chang insisted that the deletion was not specifically aimed at Taiwan and if
APEC organizers made any gestures to demean Taiwan, “we will lodge a protest at
an appropriate time.”
MOFA is still investigating why the section was taken down, he added.
MOFA said that Lima commissioned its national news agency, Andina, to handle all
media-related affairs and to post APEC-related information on the Web site.
The APEC summit, also known as the informal economic leaders’ meeting, will be
held in Lima from tomorrow through Sunday this year.
The reception is scheduled for tomorrow and business networking, tours and golf
are planned for Sunday.
Leaders scheduled to speak at the summit include Australian Prime Minister Kevin
Rudd, Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper, Chilean President Michelle
Bachelet, South Korean President Lee Myung-bak, US President George W. Bush and
Chinese President Hu Jintao (胡錦濤).
Former vice president and honorary Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) Chairman Lien
Chan (連戰) is standing in for Ma in Lima this year. Lien is the highest-ranking
Taiwanese official to attend the event.
Former president Chen Shui-bian (陳水扁) proposed that former vice president Li
Yuan-zu (李元簇) be the APEC representative, but the proposal was voted down by
Beijing.
Chen
returns to Tucheng detention center
STABLE: Doctors said the former president’s medical condition was stabilizing, but he still refuses to eat. Chen’s lawyer said that he misses his grandchildren
By Ko Shu-ling
STAFF REPORTER, WITH AFP
Thursday, Nov 20, 2008, Page 3
|
Supporters of
former president Chen Shui-bian chant slogans to criticize Chen’s
ongoing detention outside a public hospital in Banciao, Taipei County,
yesterday. Around 100 supporters protested outside the hospital,
criticizing the ongoing detention as political persecution. PHOTO: AFP |
Former president Chen Shui-bian (陳水扁) was released from hospital and
returned to a detention center yesterday after doctors said Chen was in stable
condition, although he still refused to eat.
Chen left the Taipei County Hospital in Banciao (板橋) by ambulance while dozens
of supporters gathered and honked air horns as he was driven back to the Taipei
Detention Center in Tucheng (土城), Taipei County.
Chen has refused to eat since he was incarcerated last Wednesday. He was rushed
to the Far Eastern Memorial Hospital on Sunday for a check-up after he
complained about soreness and discomfort in his chest. He was transferred to
Taipei County Hospital on Monday for security reasons.
Yang Chang-bin (楊長彬), county hospital deputy director, yesterday said that Chen
could get in and out of bed by himself, bloating had been reduced and the ketone
reaction in his urine had improved. His blood pressure, heartbeat, blood sugar,
body temperature and liver functions remained normal, Yang said.
Chen’s lawyer, Cheng Wen-long (鄭文龍), told reporters after visiting the former
president that his client was still weak and felt cold most of the time. The
former president also said he missed his four grandchildren very much, Cheng
said.
Cheng said he would try to get some photographs of the former president’s four
grandchildren and bring them to his client.
In related developments, Next Magazine yesterday said that prosecutors were
looking into whether Chen and his former right-hand man Chiou I-jen (邱義仁) had
pocketed US$25 million in diplomatic funds.
The magazine alleged that Chiou claimed US$5 million in cash from the foreign
ministry to promote Taiwan’s WHO bid. Another US$20 million, which Chiou also
received in cash, was supposed to be given to ally Panama’s leader Martin
Torrijos as a “political donation” to prevent the country from switching
diplomatic recognition to China, the magazine said.
The magazine cited an unnamed source as saying prosecutors suspected Chen could
have deposited the cash in overseas bank accounts while he was on state visits
abroad.
In response, Chen’s office issued a statement dismissing the allegations as “a
malicious attempt to confuse public opinion” and to “smear the former
government’s diplomatic efforts.”
Meanwhile, in related news, US State Department Spokesman Sean McCormack
yesterday said they were confident in Taiwan’s democracy and its legal system.
“We have every expectation that the process will be transparent, fair and
impartial,” he said.
McCormack made the remarks in response to a question about whether the US
government has concerns about Taiwan’s legal system.
Meanwhile, Chiayi County Commissioner Chen Ming-wen (陳明文), who began a hunger
strike on Nov. 11, has agreed to start eating after his wife, Liao Su-hui (廖素惠),
visited yesterday and urged him to eat.
Legislators
bicker over assembly law
WAR OF WORDS: DPP and KMT
lawmakers traded barbs over amendments to the law, which one KMT legislator said
was sure to lead to unrest and daily demonstrations
By Loa Iok-sin
STAFF REPORTER
Thursday, Nov 20, 2008, Page 4
|
Protesters
demand amendments to the Assembly and Parade Law outside the legislature
in Taipei yesterday. The protesters walked around the Legislative Yuan,
saying that the law was unconstitutional in its current form. PHOTO: CHIEN JUNG-FONG, TAIPEI TIMES |
Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) and Democratic Progressive Party (DPP)
lawmakers waged a war of words yesterday as they accused each other of slowing
down or blocking the Assembly and Parade Law (集會遊行法) revision process.
The legislature’s Internal Administration Committee had been scheduled to review
draft amendments submitted by both parties yesterday.
However, DPP caucus whip William Lai (賴清德) protested when KMT Legislator Wu Yu-sheng
(吳育昇), the committee’s convener, said the legislature should wait for the
Cabinet to propose its own draft amendment and hold a public hearing next
Thursday.
“You’re trying to delay the [law revision] process by holding yet another public
hearing next week,” Lai said.
“We should start an article-by-article review after a general discussion today,”
he said.
Wu disagreed, saying that the goal of a public hearing was “to hear opinions
from different people, including the Wild Strawberries,” in a bid to improve the
quality of the amendment.
The “Wild Strawberry Movement” refers to a group of college students staging a
silent sit-in protest at Liberty Square in Taipei since Nov. 6. Their demands
include revision of the law.
“If the DPP is opposed to a public hearing, then you should go out and tell the
Wild Strawberries,” Wu said.
The dispute intensified when DPP lawmakers accused the KMT of having a long
history of blocking revisions to the law.
“During a meeting in 2006 over which you, Wu Yu-sheng, presided, you tried to
block the Assembly and Parade Law amendment process,” Lai said.
“I’ve always respected you, Legislator Lai, but as a politician, you should not
lie,” Wu shouted back.
“Yes, there was a public hearing in 2006, and yes, I presided over the meeting —
but it was the DPP that opposed an article-by-article review [of the Assembly
and Parade Law] afterwards,” Wu said.
Several DPP and KMT lawmakers joined their colleagues in the debate, but the two
sides failed to reach a consensus, leaving the Assembly and Parade Law amendment
process stalled.
Later, a few KMT legislators including Wang Jin-shih (王進士) expressed concern
that revising the Assembly and Parade Law might result in too many protests.
If the requirement for event organizers to seek approval from law enforcement
authorities before holding a rally is rescinded, “then there may be
demonstrations every day, which could lead to social unrest,” Wang said.
“As long as people don’t open their minds, and bear hatred in their minds, they
will take it to the street every day,” Wang added.
Ma Ying-jeou
as musical instrument
Thursday, Nov 20, 2008, Page 8
“I am not into wishful thinking and I am not naive. Our efforts have obviously
generated a lot of goodwill across the Taiwan Strait,” President Ma Ying-jeou
(馬英九) said on Tuesday, claiming that his conciliatory cross-strait policies were
bearing fruit.
In this case, the piece of fruit was rather small: Ma had been referred to as
“president” on APEC’s official Web site.
Shortly after it came to light, Ma chalked up this minor development as a
victory for Taiwanese diplomacy. But then the fruit became rotten: the Web site
changed, and the page that described Ma as the “president of Chinese Taipei” was
nowhere to be seen.
The Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) administration was quick to find excuses for
the temporary nature of its triumph, downplaying the significance of the setback
rather than facing it squarely and pinpointing the reasons for the charade.
The Presidential Office insisted yesterday that the Web page — however
short-lived — was “a diplomatic breakthrough nonetheless,” while the Ministry of
Foreign Affairs said the scrapping of the page was not directed at Taiwan
because the entire section introducing APEC members had been taken down.
It is really quite sad to see the Ma government mastering and enhancing the
petty point scoring, absurd rationalizations and complacency of the previous
government over what was likely a small but “beautiful mistake” on the part of
the unsuspecting APEC host country.
Meanwhile, China continues to have a field day slapping Taiwan around on the
international stage as Taiwan’s diplomats pore through their dictionaries
looking for other ways of saying “diplomatic breakthrough.”
While some political observers suspect that China was responsible for the
removal of the Web page, others wonder whether some sort of much more elaborate
conspiracy is at hand, with the Ma government in a two-step with Beijing’s
strategists. Could it be, they wonder, that the whole thing was set up to make
the Ma government look good at home by having him briefly addressed as president
— thus making China look reasonable and friendly toward Taiwan — before having
the page removed on the assumption that no one in Taiwan could be bothered to
look at the page later on?
Such ludicrous theories suggest that far too many analysts have little real
information to share. What can be confirmed is this: The Ma government has a
greater interest in deploying security forces that violate citizens’ rights than
standing up to China’s symbolic and procedural aggression at international
forums such as APEC.
Ma has insisted that his “mutual non-denial” approach to diplomacy is working
well and that China has responded to it positively.
This self-assessment does not sit well with available evidence. When Association
for Relations Across the Taiwan Strait Chairman Chen Yunlin (陳雲林) met Ma earlier
this month, he addressed him as “You ... you … you ...” rather than the large
number of respectful options that were available to him.
The truth is that China is playing Ma like a musical instrument that is
oblivious to its own sound. Another word for such a person is “naive” and
another expression for such a person’s state of mind is “wishful thinking.”
A lesson in
rights for this ‘stupid president’
By Lin Chien-cheng
林健正
Thursday, Nov 20, 2008, Page 8
‘Police ruthlessly disperse protesters who shout slogans against Ma, and some
have even been taken in for questioning just for booing Minister of Justice Wang
Ching-feng.’
Allen Chu (朱成志), a stock market analyst who often appears on television,
recently wrote an article for investment advice magazine Marbo Weekly under the
title “A lesson in credit transactions for a stupid president.” Subsequently,
the Financial Supervisory Commission ordered Chu to stop writing articles,
giving lectures or participating in TV talk shows for one month on the grounds
that his article contained incorrect figures that would mislead investors and
disrupt the stock market.
There is no precedent for a government department imposing such a severe penalty
on a market analyst just for quoting incorrect figures.
Many investment analysts, including Chu, predicted that the TAIEX would rise to
above 10,000 points following the election of President Ma Ying-jeou (馬英九), but
the index has plunged since Ma’s inauguration on May 20. The commission has not
imposed any penalties on these analysts for “misleading investors.” Many media
commentators are asking whether the real reason for Chu’s punishment was his use
of the word “stupid.”
Mistaken reports about the stock market are common in the media, so why is Chu
the only one to be punished? If the treatment meted out to Chu is going to set a
pattern for the Ma government’s handling of such cases, what will become of
freedom of speech and publication?
If criminal prosecutors operated in the same way as the commission then people
would cry selective prosecution.
In the six months since Ma became president, his government has forbidden people
from wearing anti-Ma T-shirts near the Presidential Office, ordered Central News
Agency reporters to write according to the government line and prevented
citizens from carrying the national flag, taking part in certain assemblies and
marches or even playing the Song of Taiwan.
Each time there is a big street demonstration, the government treats protesters
as suspects, blanketing the area with police and monitoring the event with video
cameras. Opposition figures are being selectively prosecuted on trumped-up
charges. Police ruthlessly disperse protesters who shout slogans against Ma, and
some have even been taken in for questioning just for booing Minister of Justice
Wang Ching-feng (王清峰).
The state of human rights after six months of Ma’s administration is plain for
all to see. Quite frankly, Ma’s performance in upholding Taiwan’s freedom and
human rights compares poorly with his predecessor’s, but as the saying goes: “A
stupid horse will never know the length of its face.”
Market guru Allen Chu gave the “stupid president” a lesson in credit
transactions. What the president needs even more is for the public to give him a
lesson on human rights.
Lin Chien-cheng is a professor in the
Department of Materials Science and Engineering at National Chiao Tung
University.